Why is nursing important?
Nursing is different today from what it was decades ago. Rapid
modernisation has brought the field of nursing to divulge further and deeper
into finding its core meaning and job scope. Therefore, this paper is going to
argue and compare the works of three authors, namely Hughes, Henderson and Carper,
with reference to other authors as well, specifically Brennan and Butts. Their
individual ideas and thoughts explain and interlink with each other in distinct
ways, elaborating the development of nursing over the years. This sets a
standard for comparison and improvement for nurses today. Besides that, experiences from our professional work are drawn and used
to relate in corresponding to the words of the authors. As a whole, this effort
will describe how the nursing field transcends from a domestic based work into achieving
a status of a profession, providing a form of service in today’s society. Not
only that, it critically explains the importance of aesthetic and ethical knowledge
necessary in moulding this profession into a comprehensive, unique and one of a
kind occupation. Basically, this work portrays a sense of affinity to the words
of the authors that relates to the daily work style of nurses today.
Nursing is and most
probably will be seen, as a female dominated field of health sciences for many
more years to come. In fact, it is relatable to its prior history during the
aftermath of World War II, when nursing was first initiated by women
domestically. Yes, women were seen as the caretakers who nurture and bring up
their families with traditional values and discipline. Women held the
obligation in sculpting a society of values and discipline, as family is the
nucleus that builds a society. Hughes (1990) stated that the moral stability of
a community is directed solidly to woman as their main responsibility. This
undeniably portrays the innate caring nature of women.
Even though nursing was
derived from a feministic home- based occupation, it is arguable that the
perspective of nursing as a domestic field of work has changed.
The answer to that lies in
its history. Evidently, Brennan (2005) points out that although Nightingale had
contributed to nursing tremendously, she however might have implemented a
system where nursing is controlled by doctors, based on their scientific medical
paradigm. Subsequently, we were perceived as assistants who merely carry out
doctor’s orders obediently as our duty, without seeing the crucial need to
question or think otherwise. Relevantly, Henderson (1964) agreed, whereby she
explains her negative nursing experience gained while she was still a student
nurse as an authoritative, regiment-based and text-book based care. Her work is
pertinent to prove on how the condition of nursing was back in the 20th century
as her student nurse experience was approximately 19 years later after World
War II. This era was when the society began to depend on the knowledge and
skills of professionals.

Hughes (1990, p. 30)
cites the work of Reverby (1987) who insists that because caring is considered
as a woman’s responsibility, it is not a prominent element that defines a
profession. Relatively, the art and beauty of care wasn’t appreciated by
society at that time. This was probably due to the restrictions of how and what
people considered as art in that era, which were concrete displays of drawings
and pictures by artists. But, caring isn’t just the duty of women, it is an art. As Wiedenbach (1964 as cited in Carper, 1978, p. 17) expresses the
transformation from a patient’s behaviour to a perception that identifies the
needs shown by that behaviour, is what the art of nursing is. Regardless of
gender, nurses have the ability to read and understand patient’s needs just by
observing their behaviour. Not only that, they are able to apply their
experiences with different types of patients to provide the best patient
centred care possible.

Well, it was at this stage
that knowledge, in the form of scientific approach towards understanding
anything and everything played a vital role in reasoning. This proved and
provided a new found gateway for innovations and unique ideas. The point where
the nursing field began to question and think otherwise based on the scientific
approach emerged. The urgency for nursing to reach a professional status
similar to medical practitioners as rapidly as possible introduced the
application of scientific positivism, which eventually paved its way to
evidence based practice. Literally, it was obvious that what nurses needed as a
stepping stone was education. Henderson (1964) contended that, for nurses to
practice nursing independently, they needed education that is provided only in
units and colleges. During her time, a college education was considered as a
higher education. But in comparison to today’s modern times, a degree or
master’s qualification in a university defines a higher education.
Comparatively, the article by (Butts, Rich & Fawcett, 2013), written just three
years ago, disputed that with the amount of knowledge expected now, a post
baccalaureate education, mainly a Doctor of Nursing Practice is required in the
nursing expertise.
Realistically, the bar is
raised higher and higher in time as the quest for higher academic qualifications
is somewhat turning into a competition among nursing alliances. Furthermore, the
primary objective of nursing, which is patient care, is sadly diminishing as
more nurses opt to move towards academic nursing rather than bedside nursing.
Besides that, paper qualifications are still considered as essential
requirements in every job scope to gain promotions or a raise in salary,
particularly in the field of nursing. Factors such as, higher pay, amount of responsibilities,
question of having respect from colleagues and employers and finally, the
potential in career development are fuels that drives nurses to think that an
educational qualification is the only way to move up the career ladder. It is
arguable that, the strong grasp of the scientific approach in nursing, from the
20th century till now, influences the amount of importance given to
the education level of nurses rather than the quality of care given to
patients.
Ironically, the term evidence
based practice is a practice that is already engraved in the minds of nurses
and student nurses. Even though many decades have passed since the birth of scientific
knowledge in nursing, it still remains as the main mode of nursing education
and practice in the 21st century. Evidence based practice only plays
a small role in the broad context of nursing knowledge, but why does it still
considered the major form of knowledge in nursing?


By,
Jessica John Posko
References :
1.
Brennan, D. (2005), The social
construction of woman’s work. Journal of Nursing
Management, 13, 282-285.
2.
Butts, J. B., Rich, K. L., &
Fawcett, J. (2013). The future of nursing: How important is discipline-
specific knowledge? A conversation with Jacqueline Fawcett. Nursing Science Quarterly, 25(2),
151-154. doi: 10.1177/0894318412437955
3.
Carper, B. A. (1978), Fundamental
patterns of knowing in nursing. Advances
in Nursing Science, 1(1), 13-24.
4.
Henderson, V. A. (1964), The
nature of nursing. American Journal of
Nursing, 64(8), 62-68.
5.
Hughes, L. (1990),
Professionalizing domesticity: A synthesis of selected nursing historiography. Advances in Nursing Science, 12(4), 25-31.
Comments
Post a Comment